publications full of ideas
Cash-Out Options
Things to Consider Before Jumping In


With the rise in health insurance costs and changing work demographics, employers nationwide are considering innovative benefit designs that are intended to not only contain costs but also provide employees greater flexibility toward benefit selection.

Enter the cash-out option in a cafeteria plan. This can include:

  • Unused employer-provided flex credits or additional credits for declining listed benefits;
  • Incentive payments for declining health insurance coverage – i.e. a strictly “cash in lieu of benefits” arrangement; or
  • A plan that offers deferral of flex credits to a 401(k) plan (such plans must offer a cash-out option).

While a cash-out benefit option is valuable in that it helps maximize employee choice (which can be especially useful when employing a wide range of employees with different interests), as with any benefit structure, it is important to consult with knowledgeable employee benefits counsel to assess the pros and cons before jumping in.

Many laws can affect a cash-out arrangement, including (but not limited to):

  • Incentives to opt out of health insurance can trigger concerns under the Medicare Secondary Payer and TRICARE incentive prohibition rules;
  • Directing too many flex credits to an FSA can lead to the FSA no longer being an “excepted benefit”;
  • Depending on whether the cash-out option is conditioned on proof of other group health insurance coverage, the amount of the cash-out can affect affordability calculations under the Employer Mandate;
  • Offering opt-out incentives to high-claims employees could be interpreted as discriminatory under HIPAA, ADEA, etc.; and
  • The compensation under a cash-out option may count as part of an employee’s “regular rate” of pay for purposes of calculating overtime under the FLSA.

The law is developing around cash-out features and should be continually monitored. For example, the United States Supreme Court recently declined to hear a 9th Circuit case that determined cash-out payments do in fact contribute to compensation calculations for overtime. This precedent is only binding in the 9th Circuit, but it affects employers nationwide who want to be circumspect about benefit offerings.¹

None of this means that employers cannot or should not utilize cash-out options – you simply need to be mindful of the issues. There are ways to address these issues. For example, you could adjust wages or benefit offerings to offset overtime costs or you could direct the cash-out options to a 401(k) deferral to take advantage of an FLSA exception. Solutions are only limited by your imagination as tempered by legal constraints and risk tolerance in the absence of clear guidance.


¹Specifically, the 9th Circuit includes Alaska, Arizona, California, Hawaii, Idaho, Montana, Nevada, Oregon, and Washington.

Brenna Davenport, an attorney no longer with Poyner Spruill, was the original author of this article.

Physical Address: 301 Fayetteville Street, Suite 1900, Raleigh, NC 27601

related information

what's new at the firm

Poyner Spruill Continues Growth, Welcomes Five New Attorneys


RALEIGH, SEPTEMBER 14, 2017 – Poyner Spruill, a commercial law firm with offices across the state, is pleased to announce Dylan Castellino, Kate Dewberry, Cheslie Kryst, and Hannah Munn have joined the firm as associates, and Emily Meeker has joined as Of Counsel.

In fond memory of Howard Chalk Broughton, devoted member of the Poyner Spruill family for twelve years


McIntyre Leadership Challenge Excites, Ignites, and Inspires Youth


Mike McIntyre recently announced at the NC Bar Association Annual Meeting, his new Youth Leadership Challenge. The Youth Leadership program will provide opportunities for civic engagement to High School students and community leadership.

Webinar: ERISA Fiduciaries, Data Privacy and Cybersecurity Risks: HIPAA, HITECH, and ERISA Preemption of State Data Breach Laws


This CLE webinar will provide guidance to employee benefits counsel on trends in data breaches for ERISA healthcare and retirement plans, lessons from recent BCBS/Anthem litigation, ERISA fiduciary obligations, ERISA preemption of state data breach laws, and contractual risk mitigation with third-party administrators (TPAs).

Poyner Spruill Attorneys Honored by Chambers USA in Seven Practice Areas


RALEIGH - Chambers USA: America's Leading Lawyers for Business has ranked seven practice areas and sixteen Poyner Spruill LLP attorneys as leaders in their respective fields. Poyner Spruill received rankings, which identify the firm as a leader in North Carolina, for outstanding work in the following practice areas: